Why the Costco Sets Were Removed From the 2025 Topps Binder

The first page of the 200-card 2025 Topps Flagship Binder

Don't get me wrong. I love the Costco...I mean...the Topps Flagship Collection insert sets that are exclusive to the Costco Super Boxes. Since 2023, these have been a nice complement to my collection. But you know me and patience when it comes to the Hobby, we don't really see eye to eye. So when a daring person on the Bay puts up a full set on a reasonable BIN, I'll bite.

Now, if I was an Athletics team fan, I'd be upset to find out that none of my favorite players were even included in the 2023 set. If I was a Nationals team collector, I'd be upset as well to find that Topps didn't have anyone representing my team in the 2024 set.

If I was a White Sox team collector, I'd be upset to find that only one player, Luis Robert, Jr, was worthy of making the 2023 set. But would I forgive them knowing that in 2024, Topps would include two White Sox cards in the 100-card set? Probably not only because both cards in that year's set was of, again, Luis Robert Jr (the man was the subject of both card #'s 11 AND 21!!!).

2024 Topps Flagship Collection Luis Robert, Jr. #11

2024 Topps Flagship Collection Luis Robert, Jr. #21

But I'm not a team collector. I'm a set collector. I need EVERY CARD! So I'm not upset at any of the above situations. Not at all.

What I'm kind of miffed about is the fact that the 2023 Flagship cards are as thick as a regular relic card. They are the same thickness of two regular base cards. Which means that I can't put them back to back in an Ultra-Pro Platinum page as I do with almost every other card in the binders. Each card gets it's own page. 

"What's the big deal?" most people would ask. "Why should you be upset? At least you can read the backs of each card without having to take the card out and...heaven forbid...put it back and risk dinging the corners."

Because the more plastic pages used, the less space I have for the cards. Putting cards back to back allows me to put a 792-card set in 44 pages instead of 88. And when it comes to a six-inch binder, space, which I had thought would be enough, suddenly isn't.

In my Anatomy of a Six-Inch Binder post for the 2025 Topps set, I listed the 100-card Flagship Collection set as one of the many sets contained within. Each card, double the thickness of a standard card, took up 12 pages of space, a half-inch worth of the binder. Which normally would be fine.

Except Topps produced out a second Costco-exclusive Flagship Super Box. 

To review, the first super box included 5 packs each of Series 1 and Heritage along with 3 packs of the exclusive Flagship inserts, one jumbo card, and one "companion" card.

The contents of the Series 1 Costco Super Box

Which in previous years, (2023 and 2024) were enough. But sales must have been great because Topps decided to distribute a second Super Box, this time containing 5 packs each of Series 2 and Archives along with the bonus packs and jumbo/companion cards.

The contents of the Series 2 Costco Super Box

So now what? The six-inch binder as it stood at 2,161 cards, was already full to bursting. Adding another half-inch of cards and pages would make it hard to close the binder properly, with pages of the base set beginning to go over the curve of the metal, which would be as one Pokémon collector who for some reason shows up on my FB and YouTube feeds (even though I don't collect the stuff)...

BAD BINDER BEHAVIOR!!!

While binder "technology" has evolved (I've seen 12 and 16-pocket pages, zippers, etc), nothing beats a six-inch d-ring binder. NOTHING. But still, these new binders would not be enough to hold the cards of even one regular set. So no, I'm not interested (but if one of these binder companies want to send me a sample to prove me wrong *hint, hint*, please email me at bdj610@hotmail.com).

So back to the point.

I've decided to take the Costco Flagship set out of the six-inch and move both sets into it's own one-inch binder. 

 

The binder for the Costco Flagship.

Yes, again, the picture isn't the greatest. But you can see that the binder will hold the cards just fine. 

The transition page from Series 1 and 2.

This is not a precedent. I've separated huge insert sets from binders before:

• 2007 Topps Generation Now...582 cards
• 2010 Topps The Cards Your Mom Threw Out (Original Backs)
• 2011 Topps 60 Years of Topps + Lost Cards (Original Backs)

The last two are in the same binder. No sense in separating. They look good together.

Taking the spot filled by the Costco Flagship sets are a master set of 2025 Topps All-Star Game, which was a product with it's own mega box introduced last summer during the ASG break. The set consists of:

• 100 base cards
• 25 Hometown Heroes cards, featuring players past and present of the Atlanta Braves, honoring the team hosting the event
• 25 Classic Swings cards
• 50 All-Star Game Greats, recognizing players from past ASG's

Replacing 100 cards that are, again, twice as thick as regular cards, with 200 is an even exchange space wise. And the binder can now claim a whopping 2,261 cards...

Two thousand, two hundred sixty-one cards

And everything still fits comfortably in the binder.

Still is heavy as heck though...

Sincerely,

JayBee Anama